Timezone: »
A common form of counterfactual reasoning is based on the notion of twin network which is a causal graph that represents two worlds, one real and another imaginary. Information about the real world is used to update the joint distribution over the network's causal mechanisms which is then used for hypothetical reasoning in the imaginary world. This is in contrast to associational and interventional reasoning which involve a causal graph over a single world that we shall call a base network. In this paper, we study the complexity of counterfactual reasoning in twin networks in relation to the complexity of associational and interventional reasoning in base networks. We show that counterfactual reasoning is no harder than associational/interventional reasoning in the context of two computational frameworks. One of these is based on the notion of treewidth and includes the classical variable elimination and jointree algorithms. The second, more recent framework is based on the notion of causal treewidth which is directed towards causal graphs used in counterfactual reasoning (e.g., structural causal models). More specifically, we show that the (causal) treewidth of a twin network is at most twice the (causal) treewidth of its base network plus one. This means that if associational/interventional reasoning is tractable then counterfactual reasoning is also tractable. We further extend our results to a form of counterfactual reasoning that is more general than what is commonly discussed in the literature. We finally present empirical results that measure the gap between the complexities of counterfactual reasoning and associational/interventional reasoning on random networks.
Author Information
Yunqiu Han (University of California, Los Angeles)
Yizuo Chen (University of California, Los Angeles)
Adnan Darwiche (UCLA)
More from the Same Authors
-
2021 : Causal Inference Using Tractable Circuits »
Adnan Darwiche -
2017 Poster: Tractability in Structured Probability Spaces »
Arthur Choi · Yujia Shen · Adnan Darwiche -
2016 Poster: Learning Bayesian networks with ancestral constraints »
Eunice Yuh-Jie Chen · Yujia Shen · Arthur Choi · Adnan Darwiche -
2016 Poster: Tractable Operations for Arithmetic Circuits of Probabilistic Models »
Yujia Shen · Arthur Choi · Adnan Darwiche -
2016 Oral: Tractable Operations for Arithmetic Circuits of Probabilistic Models »
Yujia Shen · Arthur Choi · Adnan Darwiche -
2015 Poster: Tractable Learning for Complex Probability Queries »
Jessa Bekker · Jesse Davis · Arthur Choi · Adnan Darwiche · Guy Van den Broeck -
2014 Poster: Decomposing Parameter Estimation Problems »
Khaled Refaat · Arthur Choi · Adnan Darwiche -
2013 Poster: On the Complexity and Approximation of Binary Evidence in Lifted Inference »
Guy Van den Broeck · Adnan Darwiche -
2013 Spotlight: On the Complexity and Approximation of Binary Evidence in Lifted Inference »
Guy Van den Broeck · Adnan Darwiche -
2013 Poster: EDML for Learning Parameters in Directed and Undirected Graphical Models »
Khaled Refaat · Arthur Choi · Adnan Darwiche -
2009 Poster: Approximating MAP by Compensating for Structural Relaxations »
Arthur Choi · Adnan Darwiche