LASeR: Learning to Adaptively Select Reward Models with Multi-Arm Bandits

Reward Models (RMs) are crucial to aligning large language models (LLMs), but the degree to which an RM specialized to one task (e.g. writing) generalizes to new tasks (e.g. math) is often not known a priori, often making using only one fixed RM to train LLMs suboptimal. However, optimizing LLMs with multiple RMs simultaneously can incur a prohibitively high computational cost and lead to conflicting signals from different RMs that may degrade performance. To address these challenges, we introduce LASeR (Learning to Adaptively Select Rewards), which frames reward model selection as a multi-armed bandit problem, iteratively and efficiently training LLMs using multiple RMs by selecting the most well-suited RM for each instance. On commonsense and math reasoning tasks, we show that LASeR boosts iterative LLM training, improving the absolute average accuracy of Llama-3-8B over three datasets by $2.67$% over an ensemble of RM scores while also showing superior efficiency (e.g., a $2\times$ speedup). Moreover, on WildChat (open-ended instruction-following tasks), LASeR leads to a $72.69$% AlpacaEval win rate over the RM score ensemble baseline. Extending to long-context generation, LASeR improves by $2.96$ F1 points (avg.) on single-document QA tasks and $2.97$ F1 points on few-shot learning over the RM score ensemble baseline with best-of-$n$ sampling. We include our code in the supplementary.