SimpleStrat: Diversifying Language Model Generation with Stratification

Generating diverse responses from large language models (LLMs) is crucial for applications such as adversarial testing, search, and synthetic data generation, where diversity provides distinct answers across generations. Previous approaches rely solely on increasing the temperature, sacrificing quality. Furthermore, the model's next-token probabilities may not be representative of the true answer distribution. To combat these challenges, we propose SimpleStrat, an alternative that uses the language model itself to partition the solution space into strata from which to sample. To measure resampling diversity, we introduce CoverageQA, a dataset of underspecified questions with multiple equally plausible answers. We propose measuring resampling diversity as the KL Divergence between the output distribution and the uniform distribution over valid ground truth answers and use recall as an alternative when assessing proprietary models. On CoverageQA, SimpleStrat improves diversity across all temperatures, showing orthogonal benefits. Quantifiably, we achieve as much as 2X better recall when applied to GPT-4o, and an average reduction in KL divergence by 0.36 when applied to Llama 3. Furthermore, we show that SimpleStrat achieves more resampling diversity at temperature T=0 than scaling temperature to T=1 on creative writing, an open-ended domain. Implementation and dataset available at https://github.com/jwong8314/simplestrat.