[Re] Replication Study of DECAF: Generating Fair Synthetic Data Using Causally-Aware Generative Networks

Velizar Shulev · Paul Verhagen · Shuai Wang · Jennifer Zhuge

Hall J #1004

Keywords: [ ReScience - MLRC 2021 ] [ Journal Track ]

[ Abstract ]
[ Poster
[Paper PDF]
Tue 29 Nov 2 p.m. PST — 4 p.m. PST


We attempt to reproduce the results of "DECAF: Generating Fair Synthetic Data Using Causally-Aware Generative Networks". The goal of the original paper is to create a model that takes as input a biased dataset and outputs a debiased synthetic dataset that can be used to train downstream models to make unbiased predictions both on synthetic and real data. We built upon the (incomplete) code provided by the authors to repeat the first experiment which involves removing existing bias from real data, and the second experiment where synthetically injected bias is added to real data and then removed. Overall, we find that the results are reproducible but difficult to interpret and compare because reproducing the experiments required rewriting or adding large sections of code. We reproduced most of the data utility results reported in the first experiment for the Adult dataset. Though the fairness metrics generally match the original paper, they are numerically not comparable in absolute or relative terms. For the second experiment, we were unsuccessful in reproducing results. However, we note that we made considerable changes to the experimental setup, which may make it difficult to perform a direct comparison. There are several possible interpretations of the paper on methodological and conceptual levels that made it difficult to be confident in the reproduction. Although we were not able to reproduce the results in full, we believe methods like DECAF have great potential for future work.

Chat is not available.